NV Vilmart Grand Cellier d'Or.
Started off being sharp and sweet with the oak very much protruding. As the evening evolved this got worse and worse. Plenty of oak but no 'matiere' in the base wine to be of any real interest. 12/20

2000 Voirin-Jumel Grand Cru Cramant.
Toasty and lots of upfront flavour. Great Chardonnay purity and finesse, good drinking now and needs no cellaring. 16/20
NV Grand Cru

NV Voirin-Jumel Grand Cru Cramant.
No less interesting than the 2000 Vintage wine. More youthfull, very pure Cramant style with elegant citrus and lime. 16/20

NV Roses de Jeanne Blanc de Noirs.
Aube wine from Celles-sur-Ource. A compact rich style but maybe just a little simple and lacking any freshness or interest. A tad boring. 13/20

2002 Nuits-St-Georges 'Les Meurgers' Domaine Hudelot-Noellat.
Pale and quite feeble on the nose and palate. Disappointing. Poor. 10/20

1998 Chambolle-Musigny 'Les Athets' Domaine Tardy.
Big rich oaky style. More like a Bordeaux than a Burgundy. Some people would like this style - I do not. 12/20